Chairman Logothetis Statement on the Proposed Permanent Broker-Dealer Inspection Program

Remarks as prepared for delivery

I am pleased that today, after more than a decade of operating a temporary program for inspecting auditors of broker-dealers, the Board will consider a proposal to establish a permanent program.

This is a sensible, commonsense reform that will provide certainty to broker-dealers and their auditors going forward and is one more step in our efforts to modernize and strengthen the PCAOB to ensure it can fulfill its mission for many years to come.

This is a top priority for me, and I believe it is for Board Member Calabria as well, who generously devoted his time and expertise to help develop the proposal.

The proposal is designed to focus our inspection resources where the risk to investor assets are more pronounced and therefore is in keeping with our “back-to-basics” mandate.

I believe this proposal is grounded in common sense and faithful to our core investor protection mission. I will leave it to my colleagues to share their own views shortly.  But first, I want to make a few points.

Congress gave us discretionary authority over broker-dealer audits in 2010, along with latitude to tailor our inspections by, for example, differentiating among classes of broker-dealers, considering whether differing inspection schedules are appropriate, and exempting certain accounting firms from the program. 

In 2011, we began inspections under the interim regime. That program was always meant to be temporary. Its implementation over the past decade provided evidence of where our oversight can have the greatest impact.

Today’s proposal applies the lessons learned over those years, particularly in terms of which engagements carry the most risk. Using our inspection experience to focus on maximizing our impact is exactly the kind of modernization this Board is pursuing across our inspection program.

As we set out on this work, we asked an important question: where does PCAOB inspection over broker-dealer audits protect investors most?  

The answer, I think, centers on firms that carry, or clear, customer accounts, meaning those that hold investors' cash and securities.  In the release, these are generally called “compliance report filers.” 

They account for about 99% of the net capital that is required to be held across all broker-dealers pursuant to the SEC’s Net Capital Rule, and more than 80% of broker-dealers’ total assets.  Neither measure counts customer assets directly, but both are useful signals of where risk to investors sits. 

Our proposal follows that risk by focusing our resources on audits of compliance report filers, where customer assets are most directly at stake. Specifically, the proposal would require annual inspection of firms that audit more than 10 compliance report filers, and inspection at least every three years for firms with one to ten clients that are compliance report filers.

It would also result in the PCAOB providing firm-specific inspection reports, giving the public more transparency than the anonymized report we currently provide. This is something we have heard repeatedly from stakeholders:  they want more transparent, decision-useful information.

To be clear, audits of exemption report filers, the broker-dealers that generally do not hold customer assets, would still be required by SEC rules and performed under PCAOB standards, and that category of broker-dealers would remain subject to the jurisdiction and oversight of other regulators.  

This proposal should not be read as a judgment that those audits don't matter. Rather, it reflects a judgment about where the PCAOB’s inspection resources can do the most good. That is what getting back to basics means: understanding the risk, applying what we have learned, listening to our stakeholders, and concentrating our resources where it matters most to investors.

On a more personal note, as I said this past May at a Forum for Auditors of Small Businesses and Auditors of Broker-Dealers, arriving in America as a young boy instilled in me the values of integrity, hard work, and the understanding that trust, once earned, must never be taken for granted.  

I think that principle has particular resonance here. Customer assets are trust in its most tangible form. When investors hand their cash and securities to a broker-dealer, they trust that those assets are safe. Focusing our audit inspections where customer assets are held is one way for us to honor that trust. 

This is a proposal, and we want to hear from investors, auditors, broker-dealers, and others across the audit and financial reporting ecosystem. I encourage everyone to answer the questions in the release, and I look forward to learning from your feedback.

Finally, I want to thank the staff of the Office of the General Counsel, the Office of Economic and Risk Analysis, and the Division of Registration and Inspections. Their expertise and hard work made today's proposal possible. I also want to thank Board Member Calabria and his staff. Their thoughtful work and careful attention to detail helped shape this proposal, and it is stronger for it.