Working Paper: The Costs of Waiving Audit Adjustments

Paper Authors:  Preeti Choudhary, Kenneth Merkley and Katherine Schipper

Abstract: We provide evidence on auditors’ proposed audit adjustments and management’s disposition of those adjustments using a large sample of audits of SEC registrants by eight large accounting firms and inspected by the PCAOB between 2005-2014. We find that proposed audit adjustments are pervasive, 81% of sample audit engagements receive at least one proposed adjustment, and that managers appear to frequently disagree with auditors about the disposition of these adjustments, at least one adjustment is waived in 72% of sample engagements. We find that firms with earnings management incentives and those with poor quality financial reporting systems are more likely to benefit from financial statement audits because these factors are associated with more proposed and recorded audit adjustments relative to waived adjustments. Finally, we provide evidence consistent with the disposition of audit adjustments having consequences for financial reporting reliability. We find that the decision to waive audit adjustments is associated with a higher likelihood that financial statements are subsequently restated, while recorded audit adjustments either have no effect or improve financial statement reliability.

Download the Paper


The economic research fellows and staff economists generate high-quality working papers that inform the oversight activities of the PCAOB and are disseminated to stimulate discussion and critical comment to the benefit of the public. Working papers are preliminary materials that have not been approved by the Board and reflect only the views of the author(s).

The research topics of economic research fellows, including a description of any nonpublic data sets required for research, are presented to the Board for approval and research papers are reviewed to confirm that the topic of the paper is consistent with the researcher's proposal. That review does not, however, encompass an evaluation of the conclusions reached by researchers.