Comment Letters (Re-Proposal)

Comment Letters
No. Author Company/Organization Date
Comment Letter Number: 1 (PDF) Author Company/Organization

PCAOB Office of Economic and Risk Analysis

Date Jan. 24, 2023
Comment Letter Number: 2 (PDF) Author Michael Ploskonka, CPA, Chair, Audit and Assurance Services Committee; Amber Sarb, CPA, Vice Chair, Audit and Assurance Services Committee Company/Organization

Illinois CPA Society

Date Jan. 31, 2023
Comment Letter Number: 3 (PDF) Author Anthony J. Pugliese, CIA, CPA, CGMA, CITP, President and Chief Executive Officer Company/Organization

The Institute of Internal Auditors

Date Feb. 3, 2023
Comment Letter Number: 4 (PDF) Author Jami Shine, CIA, CRMA, CISA, CRISC, Corporate and IT Audit Manager Company/Organization

QuikTrip Corporation

Date Feb. 7, 2023
Comment Letter Number: 5 (PDF) Author Beth-Ann Martorello, CISA, CCSA, CRISC, SVP/Chief Audit Officer Company/Organization

AllianceBernstein

Date Feb. 7, 2023
Comment Letter Number: 6 (PDF) Author Chris Barnard Date Feb. 13, 2023
Comment Letter Number: 7 (PDF) Author Paul F. Schneider Date Feb. 13, 2023
Comment Letter Number: 8 (PDF) Author Dawn Belohlavek, Chief Audit Executive & Director of Internal Auditing Company/Organization

MDU Resources Group, Inc.

Date Feb. 14, 2023
Comment Letter Number: 9 (PDF) Author Surinder K Bansal, Chartered Accountant Company/Organization

Bansal & Co LLP

Date Feb. 15, 2023
Comment Letter Number: 10 (PDF) Author Mary C. Rohas, Independent Verification & Validation Manager, Audit & Consulting Team Company/Organization

Virginia Community Colleges – System Office

Date Feb. 15, 2023
Comment Letter Number: 11 (PDF) Author Jeffrey P. Mahoney, General Counsel Company/Organization

Council of Institutional Investors

Date Feb. 16, 2023
Comment Letter Number: 12 (PDF) Author Tim Hungerford Date Feb. 16, 2023
Comment Letter Number: 13 (PDF) Author Elizabeth S. Beastrom, President Company/Organization

Thomson Reuters Tax & Accounting Professionals

Date Feb. 16, 2023
Comment Letter Number: 14 (PDF) Author Karen Percent, MHA, CPA, CIA Date Feb. 16, 2023
Comment Letter Number: 15 (PDF) Author Craig Godfrey, CPA, Board Vice Chairperson; Charmaine Shellman, Audit Committee Chairperson; Jeffrey Benson, CPA, President/CEO; Bryanna Benoit, Chief Financial Officer; Corrie A. Jameson, CPA, Chief Risk Management Officer Company/Organization

CASE Credit Union

Date Feb. 16, 2023
Comment Letter Number: 16 (PDF) Author Members of the IAG Date Feb. 16, 2023
Comment Letter Number: 17 (PDF) Author Melanie Sack, Executive Director; Gillian Waldbauer, Head of International Affairs Company/Organization

Institut der Wirtschaftsprüfer

Date Feb. 17, 2023
Comment Letter Number: 18 (PDF) Author Michele Eddy Chaisson, CIA, CRMA Date Feb. 17, 2023
Comment Letter Number: 19 (PDF) Author Vanessa Teitelbaum, CPA, Senior Director, Professional Practice Company/Organization

Center for Audit Quality

Date Feb. 17, 2023
Comment Letter Number: 20 (PDF) Author Gunther Plosch, Chief Financial Officer; Melissa Clawson, Chief Audit Executive Company/Organization

The Wendy’s Company

Date Feb. 17, 2023
Comment Letter Number: 21 (PDF) Author Krista Rowe, CPA, CIA, Internal Audit Supervisor Company/Organization

Midwest BankCentre

Date Feb. 16, 2023
Comment Letter Number: 22 (PDF) Author J. Ramsey Womack III, CPA, Chair, Professional Standards Committee Company/Organization

Texas Society of Certified Public Accountants

Date Feb. 17, 2023
Comment Letter Number: 23 (PDF) Author Company/Organization

KPMG LLP

Date Feb. 17, 2023
Comment Letter Number: 24 (PDF) Author Company/Organization

Deloitte & Touche LLP

Date Feb. 17, 2023
Comment Letter Number: 25 (PDF) Author Kristin Kruse Date Feb. 19, 2023
Comment Letter Number: 26 (PDF) Author Company/Organization

Grant Thornton LLP

Date Feb. 20, 2023
Comment Letter Number: 27 (PDF) Author Company/Organization

Crowe LLP

Date Feb. 20, 2023
Comment Letter Number: 28 (PDF) Author Company/Organization

Ernst & Young LLP

Date Feb. 20, 2023
Comment Letter Number: 29 (PDF) Author Richard N. Reisig, CPA, Chair; Ken L. Bishop, President and CEO Company/Organization

National Association of State Boards of Accountancy

Date Feb. 13, 2023
Comment Letter Number: 30 (PDF) Author Brian J. Costello, Compliance & Open Banking Strategy Company/Organization

Circit

Date Feb. 20, 2023
Comment Letter Number: 31 (PDF) Author Company/Organization

Auditing Standards Committee, Auditing Section - American Accounting Association

Date Feb. 20, 2023
Comment Letter Number: 32 (PDF) Author Company/Organization

ICAEW

Date Feb. 20, 2023
Comment Letter Number: 33 (PDF) Author Company/Organization

RSM US LLP

Date Feb. 20, 2023
Comment Letter Number: 34 (PDF) Author Company/Organization

PricewaterhouseCoopers LLP

Date Feb. 20, 2023
Comment Letter Number: 35 (PDF) Author Company/Organization

Plante & Moran, PLLC; Plante Moran, P.C.

Date Feb. 20, 2023
Comment Letter Number: 36 (PDF) Author Eric E. Cohen Company/Organization

Cohen Computer Consulting

Date Feb. 20, 2023
Comment Letter Number: 37 (PDF) Author Denis Gorgemans, CIA Date Feb. 20, 2023
Comment Letter Number: 38 (PDF) Author Jackson G. Johnson, CPA, President Company/Organization

Johnson Global Accountancy

Date Feb. 20, 2023
Comment Letter Number: 39 (PDF) Author Company/Organization

BDO USA, LLP

Date Feb. 20, 2023
Comment Letter Number: 40 (PDF) Author Melissa B. Hall, CPA, CFE, CCEP, President Company/Organization

Association of College and University Auditors

Date Feb. 20, 2023
Comment Letter Number: 41 (PDF) Author Joshua R. Kirby, CIA Date Feb. 15, 2023
Comment Letter Number: 42 (PDF) Author James R. Dalkin, Director, Financial Management and Assurance Company/Organization

U.S. Government Accountability Office

Date Feb. 21, 2023
Comment Letter Number: 43 (PDF) Author Sandra J. Peters, CPA, CFA, Senior Head, Global Policy Advocacy Company/Organization

CFA Institute

Date Feb. 21, 2023
Comment Letter Number: 44 (PDF) Author Tim Hieger, BCM Testing COE Director, CPA, CIA Company/Organization

Property & Casualty Insurance Group, USAA

Date Feb. 23, 2023
Comment Letter Number: 45 (PDF) Author Tom Quaadman, Executive Vice President Company/Organization

U.S. Chamber of Commerce, Center for Capital Markets Competitiveness

Date Feb. 27, 2023
Comment Letter Number: 46 (PDF) Author Company/Organization

CohnReznick LLP

Date Mar. 2, 2023
Comment Letter Number: 47 (PDF) Author Joshua Stein, Vice President, Accounting and Financial Management Company/Organization

American Bankers Association

Comment Letters (Proposed Rule)

Comment Letters
No. Author Company/Organization Date
Comment Letter Number: 1 (PDF) Author Donna J. Fisher, Senior Vice President, Tax, Accounting & Financial Management Company/Organization

American Bankers Association

Date Aug. 17, 2010
Comment Letter Number: 2 (PDF) Author Richard F. Chambers, CIA, CGAP, CCSA, President and Chief Executive Officer Company/Organization

Institute of Internal Auditors

Date Sep. 7, 2010
Comment Letter Number: 3 (PDF) Author Company/Organization

McGladrey & Pullen, LLP

Date Sep. 9, 2010
Comment Letter Number: 4 (PDF) Author Company/Organization

Auditing Standards Committee, Auditing Section - American Accounting Association

Date Sep. 10, 2010
Comment Letter Number: 5 (PDF) Author Professor Joseph A. Maffia, CPA Company/Organization

Hunter College Graduate Program, Economics Department

Date Sep. 13, 2010
Comment Letter Number: 6 (PDF) Author Company/Organization

Institut der Wirtschaftsprüfer

Date Sep. 13, 2010
Comment Letter Number: 7 (PDF) Author Hans van Damme, President Company/Organization

Federation of European Accountants

Date Sep. 13, 2010
Comment Letter Number: 8 (PDF) Author JoAnn Guattery, Chair, Accounting Principles and Auditing Committee Company/Organization

California Society of Certified Public Accountants

Date Sep. 8, 2010
Comment Letter Number: 9 (PDF) Author C. Brian Fox, CPA, Founder & Chief Marketing Officer Company/Organization

Capital Confirmation, Inc.

Date Sep. 13, 2010
Comment Letter Number: 10 (PDF) Author Katharine E Bagshaw FCA, Manager, Auditing Standards, ICAEW Audit and Assurance Faculty Company/Organization

The Institute of Chartered Accountants in England and Wales

Date Sep. 13, 2010
Comment Letter Number: 11 (PDF) Author Kathryn W. Kapka, MBA, CPA, CIA, CGAP, Chair, Professional Standards Committee Company/Organization

Texas Society of Certified Public Accountants

Date Sep. 13, 2010
Comment Letter Number: 12 (PDF) Author Company/Organization

PricewaterhouseCoopers LLP

Date Sep. 13, 2010
Comment Letter Number: 13 (PDF) Author Cynthia M. Fornelli, Executive Director Company/Organization

Center for Audit Quality

Date Sep. 13, 2010
Comment Letter Number: 14 (PDF) Author Wendy Stevens, WeiserMazars Quality Assurance; Denis Usher, Mazars US Desk; Jean-Luc Barlet, Mazars Chief Compliance Officer Company/Organization

Mazars

Date Sep. 13, 2010
Comment Letter Number: 15 (PDF) Author Company/Organization

Deloitte & Touche LLP

Date Sep. 13, 2010
Comment Letter Number: 16 (PDF) Author Jan C. Herringer; Mark Mycio; John M. Sacco Company/Organization

New York State Society of Certified Public Accountants

Date Sep. 13, 2010
Comment Letter Number: 17 (PDF) Author Company/Organization

Ernst & Young LLP

Date Sep. 13, 2010
Comment Letter Number: 18 (PDF) Author Company/Organization

Grant Thornton LLP

Date Sep. 13, 2010
Comment Letter Number: 19 (PDF) Author Company/Organization

KPMG LLP

Date Sep. 13, 2010
Comment Letter Number: 20 (PDF) Author Tom Quaadman Company/Organization

United States Chamber of Commerce Center for Capital Markets Competitiveness

Date Sep. 13, 2010
Comment Letter Number: 21 (PDF) Author Company/Organization

Crowe Horwath LLP

Date Sep. 13, 2010
Comment Letter Number: 22 (PDF) Author Company/Organization

Mayer Hoffman McCann P.C.

Date Sep. 13, 2010
Comment Letter Number: 23 (PDF) Author James R. Dalkin, Director, Financial Management and Assurance Company/Organization

United States Government Accountability Office

Date Sep. 13, 2010
Comment Letter Number: 24 (PDF) Author Company/Organization

BDO USA, LLP

Date Sep. 13, 2010
Comment Letter Number: 25 (PDF) Author Company/Organization

AuditConfirmations, LLC

Comment Letter Number: 26 (PDF) Author Kevin V. Wydra, CPA, Chair, Audit and Assurances Services Committee; James Gerace, CPA, Vice Chair, Audit and Assurances Services Committee Company/Organization

Illinois CPA Society

Date Sep. 13, 2010
Comment Letter Number: 27 (PDF) Author Howard B. Levy, Sr. Principal and Director of Technical Services Company/Organization

Piercy Bowler Taylor & Kern, Certified Public Accountants

Date Oct. 4, 2010
Comment Letter Number: 28 (PDF) Author Joseph A. Maffia, CPA Date Aug. 23, 2022

Comment Letters (Concept Release)

Comment Letters
No. Author Company/Organization Date
Comment Letter Number: 1 (PDF) Author Dan Mahaffey Date Apr. 15, 2009
Comment Letter Number: 2 (PDF) Author Tim Young Company/Organization

Joseph Decosimo and Company, LLC

Date Apr. 20, 2009
Comment Letter Number: 3 (PDF) Author Company/Organization

AuditConfirmations, LLC

Date May 14, 2009
Comment Letter Number: 4 (PDF) Author Mark Lyle Company/Organization

PricewaterhouseCoopers LLP

Date May 18, 2009
Comment Letter Number: 5 (PDF) Author Frank Maguire, Vice President, Business Planning & Strategy Company/Organization

RPost, the Registered E-mail® Company

Date May 26, 2009
Comment Letter Number: 6 (PDF) Author Company/Organization

United States Government Accountability Office

Date May 28, 2009
Comment Letter Number: 7 (PDF) Author Company/Organization

American Accounting Association, Auditing Section, Auditing Standards Committee

Date May 28, 2009
Comment Letter Number: 8 (PDF) Author JoAnn Guattery, Chair, Accounting Principles and Auditing Standards Committee Company/Organization

California Society of Certified Public Accountants

Date May 28, 2009
Comment Letter Number: 9 (PDF) Author Company/Organization

Institut der Wirtschaftsprüfer

Date May 29, 2009
Comment Letter Number: 10 (PDF) Author Company/Organization

The Institute of Chartered Accountants in England and Wales

Date May 29, 2009
Comment Letter Number: 11 (PDF) Author Company/Organization

Federation of European Accountants

Date May 29, 2009
Comment Letter Number: 12 (PDF) Author Company/Organization

McGladrey & Pullen, LLP

Date May 29, 2009
Comment Letter Number: 13 (PDF) Author Company/Organization

PricewaterhouseCoopers LLP

Date May 29, 2009
Comment Letter Number: 14 (PDF) Author Cynthia M. Fornelli, Executive Director Company/Organization

Center for Audit Quality

Date May 29, 2009
Comment Letter Number: 15 (PDF) Author Jon R. Hoffmeister, Chair, Audit and Assurance Services Committee Company/Organization

Illinois CPA Society

Date May 29, 2009
Comment Letter Number: 16 (PDF) Author Brian Fox, Vice President Company/Organization

Capital Confirmations, Inc.

Date May 29, 2009
Comment Letter Number: 17 (PDF) Author Company/Organization

BDO Seidman, LLP

Date May 29, 2009
Comment Letter Number: 18 (PDF) Author Company/Organization

Deloitte & Touche LLP

Date May 29, 2009
Comment Letter Number: 19 (PDF) Author Company/Organization

Grant Thornton LLP

Date May 29, 2009
Comment Letter Number: 20 (PDF) Author Company/Organization

Ernst & Young LLP

Date May 29, 2009
Comment Letter Number: 21 (PDF) Author Company/Organization

KPMG LLP

Date May 29, 2009
Comment Letter Number: 22 (PDF) Author Jean-Luc Barlet Company/Organization

Mazars Risk Management & Audit Quality

Date May 29, 2009
Comment Letter Number: 23 (PDF) Author Mary Hartman Morris, Investment Officer Company/Organization

CalPERS

Date May 29, 2009
Comment Letter Number: 24 (PDF) Author Howard B. Levy, Sr. Principal and Director, Technical Services Company/Organization

Piercy Bowler Taylor & Kern

Date Sep. 2, 2009